Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund
Public-record listing · US · https://www.fidelitycharitable.org
What they do
Largest US donor-advised fund sponsor (public charity). Fees and program guidelines are published. Litigation: Fairbairn v. Fidelity Charitable (N.D. Cal.) - donors' misrepresentation/negligence claims over a stock liquidation; judgment for Fidelity Charitable (Feb. 2021).
Public-record summary. Category: Donor-advised fund (S03). Fees: Published: 0.60%/yr admin fee (or $100 min) + investment pool expenses; no minimum contribution.
Strategies offered
- Donor-Advised Funds Public record source
Evidence score
12 points are pending because the item could not be checked from public records. If every pending item were verified, the score could reach up to 90 (limited by caps or by items that don't apply). How this is calculated.
| Category | Points | |
|---|---|---|
| Regulatory record (weight 25) | 12 / 20 | |
| Tax-controversy record (weight 20) | 16 / 20 | |
| Litigation & complaints (weight 15) | 10 / 15 | |
| Transparency (weight 15) | 8 / 8 | |
| Substance & verifiability (weight 15) | 0 / 0 | |
| Structure quality (weight 10) | 2 / 4 |
Red flags
No red flags (RF1-RF13) were triggered by the public evidence reviewed.
Evidence by item
Each line shows the points awarded, how it was checked and a source link where one exists.
Regulatory record · 12 / 20
| Item | Points | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| R1 Registration status verified for firm and soliciting individuals where required (BD/IA/state; insurance producer if relevant) | n/a | Not applicable | Public-charity DAF sponsor; donor contributions are irrevocable gifts, not securities purchases. (Charitable status itself not re-verified on IRS TEOS in this initial review.) |
| R2 No SEC/FINRA disciplinary events for the firm (10-yr lookback) | 8 / 8 | VERIFIED (nothing found) | No SEC/FINRA actions against the charity found. source |
| R3 No disciplinary events for principals/control persons (10-yr lookback) | 0 / 6 | UNVERIFIED | Officers/trustees not reviewed (Form 990 not pulled). |
| R4 No state securities-regulator or state AG actions against firm/principals | 4 / 4 | VERIFIED (nothing found) | No state AG action found by web search. Not exhaustive. |
| R5 Named licensed professionals (CPA/attorney/EA) in good standing | 0 / 2 | UNVERIFIED | Licensed-professional good standing needs state CPA board / bar lookups for named individuals; not performed in this initial review. |
Tax-controversy record · 16 / 20
| Item | Points | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| T1 Strategy is not a listed transaction / transaction of interest and not a current Dirty Dozen theme | 4 / 8 | VERIFIED | DAF gifts are not listed, but accepting non-cash assets (private stock, real estate) is adjacent to 2026 Dirty Dozen #9 (non-cash charitable schemes) (rubric: 4). source |
| T2 No DOJ Tax Division injunctions / IRC ยงยง6700, 6701 promoter cases against firm or principals | 6 / 6 | VERIFIED (nothing found) | No DOJ promoter case found. source |
| T3 No adverse Tax Court / appellate opinions involving the sponsor's prior deals | 4 / 4 | VERIFIED (nothing found) | No adverse Tax Court opinions on its program found. source |
| T4 Provides clear reportable-transaction disclosure guidance (Form 8886/8918) where applicable | 2 / 2 | VERIFIED | Strategy is not a listed transaction/TOI, so Form 8886/8918 guidance is N/A-justified (rubric: 2 = clear or N/A-justified). source |
Litigation & complaints · 10 / 15
| Item | Points | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| L1 No material civil fraud/misrepresentation litigation (firm, principals, affiliates) | 3 / 6 | VERIFIED | Fairbairn v. Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund, No. 3:18-cv-04881 (N.D. Cal.): misrepresentation and negligence claims; judgment for Fidelity Charitable (Feb. 26, 2021). Resolved (rubric: 3). source |
| L2 Complaint pattern reasonable (BBB, state AG, CFPB where relevant) | 4 / 4 | VERIFIED (nothing found) | No complaint pattern found (no BBB profile returned by BBB search API). source |
| L3 No bankruptcy/insolvency pattern among principals or affiliates | 3 / 3 | VERIFIED (nothing found) | No bankruptcy. source |
| L4 Entities in good standing with Secretary of State; legal entity names match marketing | 0 / 2 | UNVERIFIED | Secretary of State good-standing not checked: state portals checked use CAPTCHA (e.g., SC businessfilings.sc.gov); not bypassed. Needs a manual lookup or paid registry pull. |
Transparency · 8 / 8
| Item | Points | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| X1 Fees and total costs published or provided in writing before commitment | 4 / 4 | VERIFIED | Admin fee 0.60% of assets or $100 minimum; investment pool expenses published. source |
| X2 Offering documents available before commitment; Form D on EDGAR where applicable | 4 / 4 | VERIFIED | Program Guidelines published (Form D not applicable to charitable gifts). source |
| X3 Names tax counsel / opinion issuer and allows direct verification | n/a | Not applicable | No tax-opinion product; deduction rules come from the Code (Sec. 170). |
| X4 Discloses audit/examination and claim history of prior deals | n/a | Not applicable | Not a transaction sponsor with 'prior deals'. |
Substance & verifiability · 0 / 0
| Item | Points | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| V1 Underlying assets independently verifiable (e.g., interconnection agreements, utility records, deeds, dated site evidence) | n/a | Not applicable | No investment asset sold to donors. |
| V2 Placed-in-service / completion evidence for prior projects | n/a | Not applicable | Not applicable. |
| V3 Appraisals by independent credentialed appraisers (not promoter-selected) | n/a | Not applicable | Qualified appraisals for non-cash gifts are the donor's obligation (Form 8283). |
| V4 Pre-tax economic substance: investment case exists apart from tax benefits | n/a | Not applicable | Charitable gift; no investment return expected. |
Structure quality · 2 / 4
| Item | Points | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 Independent legal opinion (not solely promoter-paid boilerplate) | n/a | Not applicable | Not applicable. |
| Q2 Tax insurance verified directly with named carrier/broker (policy exists, scope understood) | n/a | Not applicable | Not applicable. |
| Q3 Fees reasonable relative to comparable offerings | 0 / 2 | UNVERIFIED | Needs a written fee comparison set of >=3 comparable offerings; not built in this initial review. |
| Q4 No guaranteed outcomes, benefit multiples or 'audit-proof' claims | 2 / 2 | VERIFIED | No guarantee/eliminate-tax language found in materials reviewed. source |
Questions to ask this firm
- Pull Form 990 officers for R3.
- Non-cash gift acceptance safeguards (for T1).
Complaints
0 complaints under review · 0 substantiated · 0 with a response from the firm.
Complaints are an allegation until a reviewer decides. We show only the category and status, never the complainant’s identity, the description or any documents. Private complaints are counted but not itemized. The firm can respond by claiming this listing.
Request a correction · Report a complaint